Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Another Victoire

There is another possible contender for Victoire Gory. In addition to Marie Victoire Gory, Marie Victoire Pitiot, and Victoire Susanne Monteise, there was a fille naturelle baptized in 1778 whose father was possibly an unnamed Gory. This woman was the goddaughter of Victoire Susanne Monteise, which leads one to suspect that the father of the child might have been a relative of hers. We have not identified the father yet, but I suspect this Victoire's father was from the same area of Bainet and probably related to Victoire Suzanne Monteise. Perhaps a cousin or uncle of hers? We assume the mother, a Beaubrun Dupuy with a Barreau maternal background, was close to the neighboring Gory and related to several of them (including Victoire Susanne Monteise). However, it is not entirely clear who the mother was. There was a Marie Beaubrun Dupuy baptized in 1766, but that seems a little too young for her to have given birth to a child in 1778. The best candidate is Marie Francoise Beaubrun Dupuy, her older sister, who was baptized in 1761. We are not sure why the priest recorded the name as Marie Magdelaine but a similar mistake was made with Victoire Susanne Monteise's name. 


If Anne Marie Joseph Gaury's mother was a Barreau, that also explains why the sister of Jean Baptiste Marillac was her godmother, since she was the widow of Dominique Barreau. The main problem is if if the Marie Victoire who died in Grand-Goave in 1783 was actually the same person as Marie Victoire Sanite. We would need more clues, but it is noteworthy that this Marie Victoire had a mother named Marie Magdelaine. Was it the same woman as Marie Magdelaine Beaubrun dit Dupuy? All things considered, this Marie Victoire with an unknown (but possibly Gory father) should be considered as a possible candidate for Anne Marie Joseph's mother. It would also be possible that she and Joseph Guillaume Deslande, a Gory on his mother's side, were the young parents of Anne Marie Joseph Gory. After all, Anne Marie Joseph's death certificate indicates an estimated age for her parents that was only 10 years higher than that for herself. That would suggest her parents were likely teenagers when she was born, which would suggest Marie Victoire Sanite and Joseph Guillaume Deslande were the probable culprits. 

Sunday, February 19, 2023

Siota or Siosta

The mother of Marie Pichot, the wife of Jean Baptiste Gaury, was a former slave named Nanette. She died a few years before her daughter with Jacques Pichot married Jean Baptiste. Her former master, a man with the surname Siota, apparently freed her. Intriguingly, her daughter would later use the surname of Siota. Using ANOM's Leogane parish records, we found that the man who likely owned Nanette died in 1746. He was from the diocese of Comminges in France and went by the name Jean Siosta.


Apparently Jean Siota may have left behind "mixed-race" progeny, too. In 1748, a Marie Francoise Siota died. She was the child of a Bastienne Siota, a free "mulatto woman" and likely the daughter of Jean Siosta. Is it possible Nanette was also the mother of Bastienne Siota? Or was she freed for another reason by Jean Siosta? It would also be great to uncover where Nanette came from and why her daughter later dropped the Pichot surname. 

Thursday, February 16, 2023

Com qualquer dois mil réis

Another classic from Novos Baianos we somehow forgot about. Again they display their mastery of the chorus and infectious melodies we expect from this band. It is unfortunate that after leaving the band, Moraes Moreira seems to have lost some of his magic.

Wednesday, February 15, 2023

Taino Revival

Taino Revival: Critical Perspectives on Puerto Rican Identity and Cultural Politics is one of those vital reads on Taino revivalism or reclamation that we devoured several years ago. Now, after a reread, we see how problematic the collection of essays here really are. With the exception of Davila, none of the academic contributors actually interviewed so-called neo-Tainos. Moreover, these essays were originally written before genetic evidence clearly confirmed the "Amerindian" component of the Puerto Rican population. While there are certainly problems with the idea of "Native American DNA" and the ways in which racial essentialism have resurfaced, today it is hard to deny that some degree of cultural and biological continuity from the pre-Columbian period to the present can be found in Puerto Rico. 

For that reason, Davila's essay is the only one that has aged well. Her interest is not in refuting or challenging the way an individual identifies, but understanding the role of memory and cultural institutions in indigeneity in Puerto Rico. Her approach rejects racial essentialism and she even shares her moments of discomfort with being perceived as Taino based on her phenotype. One Puerto Rican even asked to inspect her teeth for evidence of shovel-shaped incisors! Regardless of attempts from others to emphasize phenotype or race as a permanent biological trait, Davila's approach contextualizes Taino revivalism and might offer clues as to why "Indians" resurfaced and disappeared multiple times throughout Puerto Rican history. After all, if the past is actively deployed in the present through several process, and related to cultural authority and memory, then the disappearance and reappearance of "Indians" across the history of Puerto Rico can be analyzed without relying on the problematic category of race. 

Unlike the Taino revivalists, we are personally inclined to view the process as part of a "mestizo" Creole culture in which Africans, Europeans, and those of indigenous descent formed the population of Puerto Rico. Sued Badillo's work persuasively demonstrates this process in the Spanish Caribbean. Moreover, as the final essay in the book suggests, in what way are "neo-Taino" Puerto Ricans less indigenous than "tri-racial" Native American groups in the continental US who have received federal recognition? If indigeneity should not hinge on phenotype or assumptions of unchanging cultural expression, then we cannot dismiss this movement so easily. And for the contributors to Taino Revival who see the movement as an escape from blackness, an engagement with black Puerto Rican and Afro-Caribbean claims on Taino identity or history would be a fruitful comparative study. We cannot name the number of times people from non-Hispanic Caribbean backgrounds have asserted an indigenous ancestry. 

It also would be useful to study the landscape of Taino revivalism today, in 2023, to better assess the degree to which it really represents an attempt to make Indians out of blacks and the changes in the relationship of the Diaspora to the island and the US (colonial) state. For example, Haslip-Viera's essay was far too harsh and lumped the neo-Tainos into the same category as reactionary, pseudoscientific and frequently ridiculous fringe black groups in the US like the Black Israelites, various strands of Afrocentrism and the Nation of Islam. Such a comparison is unfair and almost certainly inaccurate for all Taino revivalists. After all, there is evidence of descent from the indigenous peoples of the Caribbean in their case. And surely not all indigenous revivalists are so obsessed with stereotypical "Indian" phenotypes or influenced by New Age and Hollywood caricatures of indigeneity. Some certainly acknowledge their African ancestry. And we are sure a few of them must be working on more historically and anthropologically informed analysis than what we have seen so far from scholars like Castanha. Perhaps Puerto Ricans need someone like Roberto Valcárcel Rojas to tackle the complex history of "Indians" in the colonial era. Anything that could add nuance and depth to our historical understanding of indigenous survival beyond the 16th century and expand our understanding of indigeneity, race, and sovereignty in a colonized region will help tremendously. 

Monday, February 13, 2023

History of Puerto Rico: A Panorama of its People

Although we have read sections of the original Spanish version of Fernando Picó's well-known general history of Puerto Rico, it was definitely worthwhile to revisit and read the entirety of the text. Picó manages to condense 500 years of history into about 300 pages and cover most of the major themes, areas in need of greater historical research, and present a coherent narrative on the formation of a people. While we believe there could have been a better historical background on the African origins of the Puerto Rican population, and perhaps a more sustained effort to integrate the diaspora with the later history of the island, this might be the best general history. Picó also proposes tantalizing possible explanations for the failures of the independence movement on the island, the legacy of racial discrimination and slavery and a rather bleak but honest assessment of the relationship with the US. To understand the current problems of Puerto Rico in the 21st century, especially the central dilemmas of independence, colonialism and economic development and the best path to reach it, Puerto Rico is a relevant case study for Latin America and the Caribbean.

Sunday, February 5, 2023

Our History and Origin

 We were not expecting too much from Abba Jiddum Gana's Our History and Origin. It's a dated bilingual pamphlet covering the history of the Kanuri of Borno. The advantage of reading such a book is the local perspective and the fact that it presents Gana's own reading of Borno traditions. As one would expect, the familiar tale of Yemeni origins is repeated here, with some references to the written materials collected by Palmer. Much of it is clearly based on oral traditions that have evolved over time. For instance, Tubba'ul Auwal of the Haimairu tribe supposedly lived 1000 years before Muhammad but he or his people were the first to place a garment around the Kaba in Mecca. References to Hind, the Quran, and obviously Islamic texts or traditions undeniably shaped how the Kanuri conceive their origins. What was interesting to us are the occasional snippets of historical information which sadly lack references. For example, the claim that Shehu al-Kanemi, son of Shehu Nengka, the founder of the al-Kanemi dynasty of Borno, was a relative of the Sayfawa. Palmer expressed a similar idea but we are still looking for confirmation of this from other sources. Gana also believed there was some evidence of Bornu and Nupe acknowleding Borno's suzerainty, a claim we do not recall ever encountering in any other text. Moreover, he asserted that the Sugurti, a Kanembu group who were originally allies of the al-Kanemi rulers, actually allied themselves with the last Sayfawa mai in 1846. We would love to hear more about this particular episode, the last attempt by the Sayfawa, with the aid of Wadai, to retake power.

Saturday, February 4, 2023

Sempre Cantando

After leaving Novos Baianos, Moraes Moreira continued to produce interesting and entertaining music. Sadly, it often lacks the youthful energy and excellent vocals of the larger Novos Baianos group. However, "Sempre Cantando" manages to be quite catchy and almost match the great choruses of his NB phase. It would have been interesting to hear NB tackle this particular song, maybe with Baby and Moraes Moreira exchanging verses.