Monday, November 16, 2026

Haitians in Chicago

We were unfortunately quite disappointed by the book entitled Haitians in Chicago. As the book by the small Haitian American Museum of Chicago, we were not expecting a lengthy and academic work on Haitians in the city. However, we did expect it to be more than AI-generated captions (very generic captions) of several pictures with little detail. The sentence structure in most of the book's paragraphs are lacking in detail, repetitive, and sound like AI-generated writing (yet full of awkward and clunky phrases that suggest a human hand at work, too). Some of the photographs are interesting and include Haitians or Haitian churches and gatherings in the North Side, Evanston, South Side, and suburbs. But, we were left scratching our heads to try to understand why the author(s) felt the need to write captions that add little depth or detail and miss opportunities to share more of the Haitian Diaspora's history in the Windy City. For example, captions very often fail to identify the people depicted and give superficial, often generic summaries. Even the bibliography is rather brief, consisting of a handful of book and websites. One was expecting to see Woldemikael's book on Haitians in Evanston and the dissertation of Courtney Joseph to see something close to a basic overview on the history of Haitian immigration in Chicago and their interactions with others. Instead, none of the earlier studies on Haitians in the Chicago area are utilized here for providing necessary detail and context to the story of Haitians in this region. Woldemikael's research in particular would have been interesting to see for an earlier study of Haitian-Americans in Evanston and race relations then and now...

No comments:

Post a Comment