Sunday, October 18, 2026
Dunama Dibalemi and the Tubu?
Saturday, October 17, 2026
Jerma Melei and Assakélé
Another thing we have been contemplating is the question of the identity of the captor of Assakélé, a Bulala princess remembered in a Kanembu song partly recorded by Henri Carbou. Although we have written about our speculative thoughts on this figure and her possible connection with the Aisa Kili of Borno traditions, we should consider other possibilities. For instance, the song identified the Borno official who seized Assakélé as Kaléa djerma Meleï. Kaléa means captive, djerma or jerma (sometimes spelled zerma) was an important officer in the Sayfawa court and Meleï is probably Mele, a Kanuri form of the name Idris sometimes seen in Kanuri girgam lists and other sources translated by H.R. Palmer. Thus, Kanembu tradition remembers a jerma named Idris whose actions here sparked or contributed to the war between the Bulala and Borno.
Is it possible that the song is actually remembering the Ngizim jerma of Idris Alooma? When mentioned by Ahmad b. Furtu in the context of the Kanem campaigns, his title had risen to wazir. Furthermore, we know from Ahmad b. Furtu's account that women related to the Bulala royal family were indeed seized during the conflict. Perhaps Kanembu tradition here is actually recalling an event right before the Kanem wars of Idris Alooma or one of those seizures of Bulala royal women during the war? Carbou claims that Kanembu tradition remembered Idris Alooma's vizier as Idris b. Harun, but that does not necessarily preclude the possibility of Idris b. Harun also being remembered as a jerma or jarma in other Kanem traditions.
Of course, without the full song this conjecture remains pure speculation. For all we know, there was a jerma named Idris during an earlier period in Borno who may have seized a Bulala princess. Assuming Kalo, Assakélé's father, was Dunama b. Salma, then we would think Melei was a jerma during the reign of Idris Alooma's grandfather. But it is still possible for the song partly translated by Carbou to have been actually referring to the Ngizim jerma, Idris b. Harun.
Sunday, February 15, 2026
Thoughts on Manan and Early Kanem
Manan, the earliest known capital of Kanem, remains an enigma. Its exact location remains unknown. Nor is there much information on the nature of this settlement or town from external Arabic sources. Oral traditions in Kanem and Borno shed little light on the matter, too. Revisiting the various sources on Manan, however, suggests its antiquity predated the 10th century. Moreover, by using what we know of later capitals in Kanem and Borno, it may be possible to reconstruct some of the characteristics of Manan. Doing so emphasizes the importance of continuity over time in the annals of Kanem and Borno. Of course, various changes took place over several centuries, but distinct features of the Kanembu, Kanuri, and various peoples living near Lake Chad persisted. In addition, reconsidering Manan as a political capital also requires rethinking what we know of early Kanem and how the consolidation of Kanem under a single dynasty required the unification of many peoples inhabiting the region.
Manan and Early Kanem in Medieval Sources
Naturally, one must begin with the medieval Arabic sources. Most of them are available in the Corpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History, edited by Levtzion and Hopkins. The first to unambiguously allude to Kanem was al-Ya’qubi in the 800s. According to him, there was a Zaghawa kingdom in Kanem. He wrote, “Their dwellings are huts made of reeds and they have no towns.”[1] It is possible that a settlement later known as Manan already existed in this century, but al-Ya’qubi did not consider it a city due to all its structures being reed huts. Intriguingly, he also described another Zaghawa group, al-HWDN, with a king from the Zaghawa. Then he mentioned an enemy kingdom called Malal, “who hate the king of Kanim.”[2] Malal, ruled by a king called MYWSY, could have been a smaller polity later absorbed into Kanem. The place name, Malal, does recall Manan and, according to one spelling, M.lan.
Besides al-Ya’qubi, the next detailed accounts of Kanem are by al-Muhallabi from the late 900s (quoted by Yaqut). This author reported that the Zaghawa had 2 towns: Manan and Tarazki, both in the first clime at latitude 21 degrees. Yet their houses were still reed huts, including the palace of the king: “Their houses are all reed huts as is also the palace of their king, whom they exalt and worship instead of Allah.”[3] This source is important as the earliest to unambiguously name a city or town of Manan in Kanem. Although the source also expresses the idea of a multiplicity of Zaghawa, it is quite clear that it is Kanem being described. Moreover, a glimpse of how the king’s authority may have been seen and what counted as wealth can be gleaned from the evidence: the king’s wealth was counted in livestock like sheep, cattle, camels and horses. The latter is especially significant due to the importance of horses in Kanem’s military power. The subjects were also said to go naked or wear skins, while the king wore silk and woolen clothes.[4] Unfortunately, there is no clear indication of where Manan was located, but the site must have had access to trade routes through the Sahara and perhaps to the east.
After al-Muhallabi, al-Idrisi wrote about Manan. To this 12th century geographer, Manan was 12 stages from Tamalma. According to al-Idrisi, “Manan is a small town without industry of any sort and little commerce. Its people breed camels and goats.”[5] This description suggests that Manan was quite small and about 8 days travel from Anjimi (Njimi, the capital of the Islamic Sayfawa rulers). Because he utilized sources from different time periods without reconciling their inconsistencies, one must interpret al-Idrisi cautiously. For instance, he also wrote that Manan was 13 stages away from the Tajuwa “town” which may have been an example of al-Idrisi inventing a town. He also claimed that Manan was where the “governor” of the country lived, who led an army mostly consisting of naked archers. This is a fascinating piece of information, but possibly evidence that al-Idrisi uncritically repeated outdated information. The reference to naked archers also suggests the Haddad, an artisanal caste group in Kanem who were known in much later times as the only people to use the bow and arrow.[6]
Last, but certainly not least, Ibn Sa’id wrote a detailed account of Kanem that drew heavily on the lost work of Ibn Fatima. The description of Kanem is that of the period of Dunama Dibalemi (c. 1210-1248). It is also thanks to Ibn Sa’id that we know Njimi was southeast of Manan. Apparently, the earlier Kanem capital was level with the angle of the Lake (Lake Chad) at longitude 51 degrees, latitude 13 degrees. Manan was specifically said to have been the capital of the pagan ancestors of Kanem’s king (in other words, the Duguwa branch of the Sayfawa). Ibn Sa’id also specifies that to the east of Manan wandered the Zaghawa and to their north, the Akawwar (presumably Teda-Daza groups in Kawar?).[7] Basically, Manan was to the southeast of Kawar (and south of the Tibesti Mountains and Borku) while to its southeast, Njimi was closer to Bahr al-Ghazal (40 miles away from this river). When one considers the higher water levels of Lake Chad in the first millennium of our era and the fact that the Bahr al-Ghazal was consistently flooded in the period from 900-1150, agricultural settlements could have thrived in Kanem.[8] Manan, located closer to Lake Chad than Njimi, would have made sense for a capital since it was closer to the areas from which the ancestors of the Sayfawa migrated: Tibesti, Borku, Kawar. At the time, it would have been able to support farmers, herders, and enjoyed closer proximity to the trans-Saharan routes. Naturally, shifting the capital to Njimi with Islamization may have been partly motivated by a desire for better agricultural land as the population moved toward greater sedentarism.
Considering Manan and Early Kanem in Today’s Scholarship
Moving into the modern era, where did scholars believe was Manan? Borno historian Muhammad Nur Alkali postulated a possible location in the Shitati region of Kanem. Some ambiguity can be seen in his attempt to locate it along the northeastern shores of Lake Chad yet also indicating a general location in the Shitati area.[9] When this region was visited by Nachtigal in the 1870s, it was in a part of Kanem that had become largely the terrain of nomadic groups. By this era, it did not neighbor Lake Chad but included numerous valleys. In total, more than 50 valleys could be found in Shitati, which also featured a natron lake. In Nachtigal’s time, most of the people residing in Shitati were Yuroa, Orabba, and Qadawa, the latter a Kanembu group of the Dibbiri with Daza ancestry. The Dibbiri, of course, appear early on in the Diwan since the mother of the first “black” mai, Salmama, was the son of a Dibbiri woman named Hawa.[10] Besides these aforementioned groups, some Kanembu and Danoa (Haddad) farmers also resided in the area. Most importantly, Nachtigal named a place called Maten el-Milah that was no longer part of Shitati. Instead, it consisted of valleys on the path to Borku.[11] It is likely a coincidence, but Manan was sometimes rendered as Matan in written Arabic sources. In the case of this place, Nachtigal reports that it was an Arabic name (Fountain of Salt) and not an indigenous one of deeper antiquity. In other words, Shitati may have once harbored the early capital of Kanem, but there is no smoking gun to irrefutably demonstrate it. In its favor is its location northwest of Njimi and proximity to Lake Chad, which enjoyed higher water levels over 1000 years ago.
Also worthy of consideration is the theory of H.R. Palmer. Palmer, a towering figure in colonial-era scholarship on Borno, was guilty of contemporary racial theories, shoddy or questionable linguistic connections, and sometimes lacking transparency for his sources. Nonetheless, Palmer did work with local elites to gather traditions or translate various manuscripts, meaning that his work is unavoidable for any serious interest in the history of Borno. In terms of Manan and early Kanem, he even gathered traditions (which appear to contain anachronisms) of Dugu’s alleged southerly campaign.[12] As for Manan, Palmer apparently connects it to the Kulu or Kuluwan region.[13] Since Madan or Malan appears to have been the place where the early mai Fune died, this is consistent with Manan as a royal capital. Against Palmer’s theory, however, is the area of Kuluwan between Kanem and Bagirmi. This is not consistent with medieval Arabic sources placing Manan to the northwest of Njimi. It was also the area where Katur, a successor of Fune, died, according to the Diwan. Ultimately, Palmer’s attempt to link Manan or Matan with the Kuluwan region is not persuasive and contradicted by the Diwan which places Manan (or M.lan) in Kanem.[14]
Manan, Malal, and Early Kanem
Besides Palmer, John Lavers also proposed an intriguing theory for early Kanem with relevance to Manan. Based on the brief description of Kanem by 9th century author al-Ya’qubi, Lavers has suggested that in c. 872, Kanem had “Zaghawa” rulers but also competed with neighboring “Zaghawa” polities. One of these groups was called Hawdin, and another was Malal. Since the ruler of Malal was called Mayusi or Mai Wasi, and the Zaghawa king Kakarah (according to one reconstruction), is it possible that the rulers of Malal superseded the early rulers of Kanem and became the reigning dynasts?[15] This theory is, of course, based on the assumption that the title of the ruler of Malal was mai and since that is the title used by the kings of Kanem and Borno, Malal’s rulers may have replaced another polity and became the dominant power in what became known as Kanem. Of course, the absence of sufficient evidence limits its probability though it would possibly correlate with the M.lan (or Manan) mentioned in the Diwan as the place where Funa died. Assuming, of course, that M.lan is equivalent to Manan and possibly related to Malal.
This theory is likewise interesting if one accepts Terio’s notion that the Zaghawa king of Kanem named by al-Ya’qubi was actually the title kireh, used by the Zaghawa for kings.[16] Alternatively, the rulers of Malal may have intermarried with the “Zaghawa” or so-called Duguwa in Kanem, since the Diwan presents Dugu as the father of Funa, the mai who allegedly died in M.lan. Furthermore, Zaghawa traditions remember a Zaghawa king of Kanem named Douk Bourmè, presumably the same Dugu recalled in Kanuri girgams and the Diwan.[17] Since dating these figures is a hazardous exercise, one can only tentatively assign dates. If the excessive reign lengths in the Diwan are meant to refer to generations as well as to stretch the dynasty back to Sayf b. Dhi Yazan, we cannot be sure which kings are semi-legendary or when their reigns may have taken place.
Obviously, this makes any endeavor to tie the polities mentioned by al-Ya’qubi with the tentative chronology of Lange problematic. Yet Lange has written, “Un souverain du nom de Funa semble avoir régné au milieu du VIIIe siècle, Arsu à la fin du VIIIe et Katur au milieu du IXe siècle.”[18] If one accepts this mid-700s date for Funa, who died in a place called M.lan that may be Manan, then it is difficult to reconcile with the theory that Malal in the 870s was in conflict with Kanem and ruled by their own independent king. Unless one proposes that Funa died in a war with Malal sometime in the 700s or later traditionists merely fused the two dynastic lines together after their intermarriage, it is difficult to square with Lange’s suggested chronology for these “Duguwa” kings. Nonetheless, the possible Malal kingdom or polity as a rival of Kanem under the “Zaghawa” could be a reference to a fusion of Zaghawa, Teda-Daza, and Kanembu elements that occurred over several centuries, consolidating as a single dynasty with regional supremacy in the 900s or 1000s. Malal may, if the theory has any validity, have been a smaller polity of Kanembu-affiliated people whose capital was changed into Manan.
Concluding Thoughts
Clearly, the location of Manan is a subject of debate. The early medieval sources provide only glimpses of pre-Islamic Kanem and must be used cautiously. Indeed, due to some of these authors never actually seeing Kanem themselves, their reports are not based on direct experience. Nevertheless, they provide a few clues about how early Kanem developed and a rough idea of where Manan could have been.
Subsequent scholars from the colonial and postcolonial eras offered new theories, but without any definitive evidence to pinpoint exactly where Manan was. With the recent confirmation of Njimi’s likely location at Tié, and the general idea that Manan was to the northwest of Njimi, we can more confidently assert that it was closer to Lake Chad. This makes the theory of Muhammad Nur Alkali plausible. The more speculative theory proposed by Lavers could facilitate identifying the placement of Manan, too. Of course, our interpretation of it relies on the questionable assumption that Manan, Malal, and M.lan were designating the same place in the medieval Arabic sources and the Diwan. Such a theory could elucidate why Manan has been forgotten in Kanuri tradition, too.
In spite of its obscurity, Manan’s position as the earliest known capital of Kanem makes it significant in the growing sedentarization and consolidation of a powerful kingdom to the east of Lake Chad by the 9th and 10th centuries. While definitive proof remains elusive, the cumulative evidence suggests that Manan was an early political center northwest of Njimi, and possibly linked to the polity of Malal that appeared in the writings of al-Ya’qubi in the 800s. With future archaeological surveys and excavations, a more confident location for Manan can be found which could meaningfully change our perception of the origins of urbanism in Kanem.
[1] al-Ya’qubi in Corpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History, 21. Some possible references to the area of Kanem may predate c. 872, but the earlier Arabic authors only use the name Zaghawa. This term may have been used very broadly for many different ethnolinguistic groups living between Nubia and the central lands of Black Africa. It is possible, nonetheless, for some Zaghawa groups to have lived as far west as Kanem in the 9th century (or earlier) and interacted with groups more closely related to the modern Teda, Daza, Bideyat and Kanembu.
[2] Ibid. John Lavers has also proposed an interesting idea about this polity, although it remains purely conjectural without additional sources.
[3] Ibid., 171. The reference to the house of the king is important, even if it was built with reed and not the monumental type of architecture Kanem and Borno developed after Islamization. The town of Tarazki is also intriguing as it bears a resemble to the later Kanem town of Daniski.
[4] Ibid.
[5] Ibid., 114. Earlier, al-Muhallabi reported that livestock and horses were the wealth of Kanem’s ruler.
[6] For more information on the Haddad, see Henri Carbou, La Région du Tchad et du Ouadaï. This group has been the subject of more than a few unlikely or highly problematic theories. Lange, for instance, has proposed identifying the Haddad or Danoa with the so-called Duguwa dynasty. There is perhaps some basis in this theory due to Haddad oral traditions remembering an early ancestor called Dana and the fact that the Haddad, an Arabic name, are referred to as Duu or Dugu by the Kanembu (See Edouard Conte, Marriage Patterns, Political Change). Contrary to the theory of a Banu Duku or Duguwa origin, the Haddad are remembered in oral traditions as sharing a common descent with the Bulala or perhaps with slaves or servile populations in Kanem during the period of Bulala rule. This theory, of course, requires deeper analysis but Carbou’s traditions of origins for the Haddad seem to only go as far back in time as the Bulala period. Interestingly, Nachtigal himself focused more on the N’Galma Dukko as a group descended from an early prince of the Sayfawa dynasty, perhaps Duku or the so-called “Duguwa” branch. See Sahara and Sudan Vol. 3.
[7] Ibn Sa’id in Corpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History, 188-189.
[8] For information on the fluctuations in the levels of Lake Chad, see “Floods, Droughts, and Migrations: The Effects of Late Holocene Lake Level Oscillations and Climate Fluctuations on the Settlement and Political History in the Chad Basin” by Karsten Brunk and Detlef Gronenborn in Living with the Lake: Perspectives on History, Culture and Economy of Lake Chad. These authors have argued that the Bahr al-Ghazal was flooded throughout this period and the Sahel zone was semiarid and subhumid. But the Sudanic savannah lands would have been humid. Their theory that the center of early Kanem in c. 900 was the Bodele region is fascinating, but this seems too far north (and east) to help one determine Manan’s probable location.
[9] Muhammad Nur Alkali, Kanem-Borno Under the Sayfawa: A Study of the Origin, Growth and Collapse of a Dynasty, 24, 57. For yet another 20th century scholar’s theory, see Zeltner’s Pages d’histoire du Kanem, which has suggested Manan was in the Egey region of Kanem.
[10] Dierk Lange, Le dīwān des sultans du (Kānem-)Bornū: Chronologie et histoire d'un royaume africain (de la fin du Xe siècle jusqu'à 1808), 70.
[11] Gustav Nachtigal, Sahara and Sudan Vol. III, 65-68.
[12] See H.R. Palmer, Bornu Sahara and Sudan for several examples of similar types of stories, legends or traditions on the kings of Kanem and Borno. Included is one 1751 manuscript which traces the origin of the first Saif to Aghani, a land Palmer claims was the Zaghawa, called Aghna (Arna) by the Kanuri.
[13] H.R. Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs Vol. I, 7, 74-75.
[14] Dierk Lange, Le dīwān des sultans du (Kānem-)Bornū: Chronologie et histoire d'un royaume africain (de la fin du Xe siècle jusqu'à 1808), 66.
[15] John Lavers, “Kanem and Borno to 1808” in Groundwork of Nigerian History, 189.
[16] Abdelkerim Souleyman Terio, Origine et évolution des Zaghawa: Du royaume du Kanem aux Etats modernes (VIIIe-XXIe siècle), 94.
Tuesday, November 11, 2025
Les coutoumes familiares au Kanem
Thursday, November 6, 2025
Kanem Under Bulala Rule
From the late 14th
century to the early 17th, the sultanate of Kanem was ruled not by the Sayfawa
dynasty whose state had originated there, but by a rival dynasty known as the
Bulala, who had driven the Sayfawa westward to Borno. How the Bulala rose to
power, how they governed Kanem, and why they eventually relocated eastward to
the Lake Fitri region are questions that the available sources address only
partially and often contradictorily. Naturally, the origin of the Bulala rulers
of Kanem is a topic worthy of close scrutiny. The exact conditions in which the
Bulala rulers have been able to seize control of Kanem from the Sayfawa dynasty
in the late 14th century, and how they ruled Kanem, are not sufficiently
explored topics. Neither are the factors that led to their exodus from Kanem
sometime in the 17th century. Some historians, using both oral and written
sources from Borno, stress the rise of the Bulala to the east, in the Lake
Fitri region. Supposedly, the early Bulala ruling lineage or dynasty claimed
descent from either a son of Dunama Dibalemi or a later mai in the late 13th century. Over time, they gradually extended
their power from a base in the east before killing a number of Sayfawa maiwa in
the second half of the 14th century. Others, however, stress an early Bulala
alliance with Shuwa Arabs, particularly the Hemet group, at some point in the
1300s and their ascent to domination of Kanem began with their attacks from the
south. Lange, on the other hand, stresses the Bulala usurpation of Kanem does
not totally explain the Sayfawa relocation to Borno. Indeed, changes in the
environment, ecological factors, and the greater fertility of the land in Borno
may have already led to the Sayfawa establishing a stronger base in Borno by
the late 13th century.
And what of Kanem under
the suzerainty of the Bulala monarchs and the conditions in which they
eventually (re)established their sultanate in the Lake Fitri region? Many
scholars and historians, such as H.R. Palmer, Muhammad Nur Alkali, Jean-Claude
Zeltner, Remi Dewiere, and Dierk Lange have relied on the Diwan,
external Arabic sources such as al-Maqrizi, the chronicles of Idris Alooma’s
campaigns written by Ahmad b. Furtu, and oral traditions, girgams, or
observations of fired-brick ruin sites in Kanem and the Bahr el-Ghazal regions
of Chad to speculate on this question. Scholars drawing on Bulala, Kanembu, and
Tunjur traditions also add further details to the poorly understood 16th and
17th centuries in Kanem. Instead of revisiting in excruciating detail the Kanem
campaigns of Idris Alooma (or, Idris b. Ali, r. 1564-1596), we believe a more
holistic view of the Bulala sultanate in Kanem requires closer examination of
Kanembu oral tradition, Bulala tradition, and an attempt at corroboration of
various traditions collected from the Bulala, Kanuri, Tunjur, Bagirmi, and
Waday states or peoples. Thus, in order to explore the question of Bulala
origins, the establishment of a Bulala-ruled sultanate in Kanem, and their eventual
decline by the 17th century, we shall endeavor to elucidate these questions
through a combination of all the aforementioned sources. It shall be
demonstrated that the Bulala sultanate was one which, if not initially of
Sayfawa descent, recreated the administrative structure of the Banu Sayf state
in Kanem.
First, one must begin
with an example of how problematic oral traditions can be for reconstructing
the history of Kanem. The traditions recorded by Landeroin for the Tilho
Mission in the beginning of the 20th century, for example, attribute the
Sayfawa arrival in Kanem after the Bulala had already ruled the area. According
to this body of tradition, the ancient Kanem subjects of the Bulala were the
Kanembu, Tomaghera, Kangou, Koubouri, Tsougourti, Djiloas and Bulala.[1]
Clearly, Kanembu oral traditions contradict the mainstream narrative of the
annals of the Sayfawa dynasty, which establish the origins of the dynasty in
medieval Kanem. However, by the 20th century, oral traditions in Kanem appear
to have postdated the arrival of the Sayfawa to the era after Bulala rule,
likely a reference to the establishment of the alifa at Mao in the 17th century. In addition, tradition attributed
the exodus of the Sayfawa to Borno due to the greater fertility of the soil,
not Bulala aggression.[2] Since these traditions are countered by earlier
written sources (Ahmad b. Furtu’s chronicle, the Diwan, external Arabic sources
from the medieval period, the traditions and narratives collected by Heinrich
Barth and Gustav Nachtigal), one must interpret them very cautiously when endeavoring
to make sense of the history of Kanem.
Another major source from
the colonial-era, Henri Carbou, also collected traditions from Kanem and nearby
regions of Chad. According to his informants, the Bulala were already mixed
with the Hemet Arabs when they chased the Sayfawa out of Kanem.[3] Later, he
wrote of the Hemat Arabs as contributing to the formation of the Bulala
tribe.[4] However, other Arabs, like the Essela faction of the Salamat, aided
Borno against the Sao. To some extent, Carbou’s interpretation of traditions
were more accurate than that of the Tilho Mission. For instance, he postdated
the arrival of the Bulala sultanate at Yao after the rise of Waday.[5] This is
in accordance with other sources for a 17th century date of the Bulala (re)establishment
of their base in the Lake Fitri region. Unlike Nachtigal, who wrote of the
Bulala as a mixture of the Kouka and Awlad Hemed Arabs, Carbou emphasized a
different origin.[6] Instead, the Bulala were a mix of the Kanembu and Hemat
Arabs who were defeated by the Tunjur, thereby leading to their invasion of the
Lake Fitri region. It is there that the Bulala mixed with the Kuka and Abou
Semen.[7] Unfortunately, the inexact genealogies of the Bulala sultans appear
to leave many rulers out, but a Sayfawa origin is asserted. Carbou favored an
origin from mai Ibrahim b. Dunama’s
son, Ali Gatel Magabirna.[8] Carbou, luckily, cites some names of Bulala
sultans remembered in Kanembu songs as Hassen, Derbali, and Kalo.[9] Kanembu
traditions further recall the Bulala as builders of walls or fortified
sites.[10] This appears to be confirmed by Ahmad b. Furtu’s descriptions of
fortified sites occupied by the Bulala in the 16th century, such as Gharni
Kiyala. Later, Carbou also recorded the Kanembu tradition of a Bulala king
named Kalo, who led the resistance to Borno in what must have been the first
half of the 16th century.[11] This Kalo was said to have been the father of a
Bulala princess named Assakele, where a community of Kanembu still resided in
the 20th century in an area named after her.[12] According to Kanembu songs,
Assakele was seized by Kalee djerma
Melei, a slave official of Borno’s ruler sent to Kanem. A war broke out between
the Bulala and Kanem when this djerma seized Kalo’s daughter by force.[13]
Lamentably, it remains
quite difficult to historicize and contextualize some of the traditions
reported by Carbou. Take the Bulala king, Kalo, for instance. His mother was
said to have been named Lafia.[14] The name Lafia appears as a mai named Lefia in H.R. Palmer’s Sudanese
Memoirs. But, in Palmer’s sources, Lafia was the father of Jil, who was the
father of Anas, who was the father of Salih.[15] Another Bulala sultan, who
fought a losing war against Muhammad b. Idris, son of Idris b. Ali (r. 1497-1519),
was named in the Diwan as Kaday b. Lafia.[16] Further
identification of Lalo may be corroborated in Kanuri traditions of Aissa Kili
bint Dunama, said to have been a daughter of the Bulala sultan Dunama b. Salma
(r. c.1500-1530).[17] Assuming Idris Alooma’s mother was the daughter of Dunama
b. Salma and not the other sons of Salma, who was the father of a Bulala
princess remembered in Kanem as Assakele, then it is likely that Dunama b.
Salma was in fact Kalo. However, traditions reported in Palmer’s Sudanese
Memoirs are contradictory about Idris Alooma’s mother. According to
Palmer, Aisa Kili succeeded Ali Gaji and ruled for 7 years. Ali Gaji was said
to have married a daughter of the Bulala ruler, Umr. Moreover, Aisa Kili was
allegedly a sister of Idris Alooma, and had lived among the Bulala.[18] Idris
Alooma’s mother, named Amsa, was said to have been a daughter of Jil ibn Bikoru
of the Bulala.[19] According to Lange, Dunama b. Salmama was one of the Bulala
kings defeated by the Sayfawa mai,
Idris b. Ali (r. c.1497-1519).[20] If so, this agrees with the chronology given
by Dewiere (c.1500-1530). As for Aisa Kili, a girgam translated by Palmer
listed her as a child of Dunama, and a “princess of the blood.”[21] This same
girgam lists the parents of Idris Alooma as Ali and Hamsa, with no indication
of Aisa Kili being the mother of Idris. As for contemporary written sources,
Ahmad b. Furtu only wrote that Idris Alooma was related to the Bulala by
marriage or parentage.[22] The only other source asserting a Bulala origin for
Idris Alooma’s mother is Muhammad Nur Alkali, who cited tradition that Idris’s
mother was the sister of the Bulala sultan, Abdullahi.[23] Consequently, one is
left uncertain about the Aissa Kili who was held by tradition to be the mother
of Idris Alooma yet also remembered as Amsa.
As the aforementioned
accounts of Landeroin, Palmer and Carbou demonstrate, the question of Bulala
origins remain an enigma. Early sources from Kanem, particularly the 16th
century writer Ahmad b. Furtu clearly identifies the Bulala as attacking
Sayfawa mai Dawud from the region of
Fitri and Madama.[24] Furtu’s account is based on a lost chronicle from earlier
in the 16th century as well as informed oral tradition. Since he lived much
closer in time to the events in question than Kanembu or Kanuri informants of
the early 1900s, it is perhaps wise to lend greater credence to Furtu’s
account. Indeed, some corroboration of it can be found in the Diwan,
which lists a number of Sayfawa rulers killed in wars against the Bulala during
the late 1300s: Dawud b. Ibrahim, Uthman b. Dawud, Uthman b. Idris, Abu Bakr
Liyatu, Sa’id, and Kaday Afnu.[25] This strongly suggests that the traditions
recorded by Ahmad b. Furtu are likely correct, and the wars with the Bulala
grew in scale during the late 14th century. It is precisely during this period
when Umar, who likely reigned from 1382-1387, moved the court to Kagha. As for
the earlier origins of the Bulala, a possible hint of an alliance with Arab
groups who had recently migrated into the region may be found in a letter to
the Mamluk sultan, Barquq, by mai
Uthman b. Idris in the early 1390s. According to said letter, the Judham Arabs
had pillaged the lands of Borno and apparently took the side of the “enemies”
of the Sayfawa, likely the Bulala.[26] Furthermore, al-Maqrizi, writing in the
15th century, wrote of the rulers of Borno waging jihad against Kanem for their
apostasy and rebellion.[27] Some have interpreted this as a sign that the
Sayfawa rulers were waging war against the Bulala sultans, who may have
received support from part of the Kanembu population. This may also be
corroborated by Fra Mauro’s mid-15th world map, indicating a place called
“Bolala” in an area roughly corresponding to Kanem or its east. This map serves
as further indication of some type of Bulala polity in the region of Kanem by
the mid-1400s. As for the Arabs mentioned in the letter to Barquq, the Judham
Arabs may have included some of the Arab groups said to have been part of the
early Bulala coalition. Indeed, according to Carbou, the Bulala were already
mixed with the Hemat when they chased the Sayfawa out of Kanem.[28] Even
Nachtigal was told by a Bulala sultan that the Bulala were a mixture of the
Kuka and Awlad Hemed Arabs.[29] As for their precise ethnic origins, Zeltner
has proposed that they may have been related to the Kuka, as they speak a
language similar to that of the Kuka, Bablia, Kenga and Medogo.[30] On the
other hand, Carbou believed that the Bulala were actually Kanembu and Hemat Arabs
who invaded them, were defeated by the Tunjur (thereby leading to their
invasion of Fitri) and then mixed with the Kuka and Abou Semen.[31]
Nonetheless, this is contradicted by the earlier testimony of Ahmad b. Furtu,
who cited traditions of the Bulala attacking Kanem from the east with the
peoples of Fitri and Madama. This implies that the Bulala were a distinct
group, although they may have included Kanembu elements in their coalition that
later conquered Kanem.
What of the alleged
Sayfawa origin for the Bulala sultans? Carbou saw their kings as descendants of
a son of Ibrahim b. Dunama of Kanem, named Ali Gatel Magabirna.[32] Barth,
however, thought the founder of the Bulala dynasty was Djil Shikomeni, said to
have been a son of Dunama Dibalemi.[33] Palmer, citing sometimes ambiguous
traditions or producing elaborate versions of them in Sudanese Memoirs,
offers more detail. According to one tradition, the Bulala of Fitri seized
power from Dawud Nikalemi, which is in accordance with Ahmad b. Furtu’s understanding.
However, in a Bulala girgam, the Bulala were presented as the son of a daughter
of the Borno sultan. The sultan of Kanem (Borno?) then attacked the N’Gizam of
Kanem for hosting the Bulala, but failed. This led to a kaygama named Dawud rebelling and ruling N’Gizam and the
Bulala.[34] Intriguingly, the Diwan does mention a kaigama called Nikali who engaged in a
civil war against Uthman b. Dawud, who only reigned for 9 months
(c.1421-1422).[35] Is it conceivable that the kaigama Dawud Nigalemi may be a partially erroneous memory of the
Nikali who overthrew Uthman b. Dawud in the tale recorded by Palmer? Further
evidence is required, but it does match the portrait of dissension and civil
wars among the Sayfawa during the period after Dunama Dibalemi’s reign. Indeed,
the Diwan similarly recalls another kaygama, Muhammad, who fought a war against Bir b. Idris (r.
1389-1421).[36] On the other hand, Palmer also wrote of the first Bulala mai being a Lafia, who lived at Kowa
Bagale near Njimi. He was said to have moved to Fitri after a war with Dunama
Dibalemi, leaving his son Jil, at Bagale.[37] Assuming that Dunama Dibalemi was
anachronistically inserted into the narrative, there was indeed a Bulala ruler
named Abd al-Jalil, son of Amiya, who killed the Sayfawa king, Dawud, in
c.1376. Moreover, Ahmad b. Furtu wrote that there were no Bulala in the days of
Dunama Dibalemi, suggesting traditions are anachronistically inserting the
illustrious 13th century ruler into the later annals of Sayfawa and Bulala history.[38]
Until further evidence is uncovered, it does appear that the Bulala ruling
dynasty developed due to the civil wars of the Banu Sayf, eventually
establishing themselves as the new masters of Kanem. By the late 19th and early
20th centuries, some of the traditions were possibly garbled or misunderstood
by European travelers and colonial officials, whereas new traditions may have
“replaced” earlier notions of the history of the Bulala. For instance,
Nachtigal was told that the name, Bulala, was derived from a leader named
Belal, the first to centralize the Bulala government.[39] Such an etymology
seems like an example of a “just-so” popular etymology and lacks the rich
details of other traditions tracing the genealogies of the Bulala sultans at
Yao. The ambiguity and unanswered questions on the origins of the Bulala
sultans is perhaps no surprise given the loss of written sources, relocation of
their dynasty to the east, and the attested intermarriage or common parentage
with the Sayfawa.
And what of Kanem under the rule of the Bulala sultans? According to Zeltner, presumably relying on traditions, the Sayfawa rulers of Borno retained control of the entire northern shore of Lake Chad well into the 15th century. After 1460, however, the Bulala ruler Abd al Jalil b. Kade fought Borno over Buluj and 2 other villages.[40] Moreover, Idris Alooma’s grandfather went to war against the Bulala twice, eventually retaking Njimi 122 years after it fell to their rivals.[41] A Bulala sultan named Kaday ibn Abdul Jalil was said to have come to Borno and died at Lada after, allegedly early into the reign of Idris’s successor, Muhammad b. Idris. According to Ahmad b. Furtu, Bulala raids on Borno territory continued into the mid-16th century. In Kanembu tradition, the Bulala sultans were remembered for their fortified sites, too, such as Garni Kiyala, Ikuma and al Agafi.[42] This is perhaps no surprise given their conflicts with the Sayfawa rulers in Borno and ongoing depredations against Borno territory. Nonetheless, the Bulala rulers had close ties with the Banu Sayf. One sultan, Abd Allah ibn Jull, performed the pilgrimage to Mecca with Idris Alooma in 1565. He was described as “not very famous” and part of the suite of the mai.[43] The previously mentioned Aisa Kili, who may have been the mother of Idris Alooma and a Bulala princess, perhaps contributed to close relations between the two royal houses.
Unfortunately, conflict
arose again in the 1570s when Idris Alooma led multiple campaigns against the
Bulala sultans. Very detailed accounts of those campaigns written by the chief
imam, Ahmad b. Furtu provides the most complete description of Kanem in this
era. Thanks to Furtu, we know of some of the Bulala fortified sites or towns.
Luckily, Magnavita et al. have also used radiocarbon dating on some sites of
fired-brick ruins in Kanem. At least two of the fired-brick sites in a cluster
of central Kanem ruin suites were dated to the period between the 1400s to the
1600s, when the Bulala sultans held sway over the region. But, their
fired-brick ruins were constructed at the slopes of the dunes and bottoms of
depressions, unlike earlier Sayfawa-era sites.[44] In addition, the town of Mao
was already an important center in Kanem by the 1570s. The Bulala political
capital of the region is not clear, but it would seem that the sultans had
managed to form alliances with the Tubu against Borno. Other groups to the east
appear to have been under the suzerainty of the Bulala sultans, as Arabs and
Kuka from the Fitri region felt compelled to meet with Idris Alooma near the
Bahr el Ghazal.[45] This implies that the Bulala sultanate encompassed not just
Kanem, but likely parts of the Fitri region and perhaps the northern part of
what became the kingdom of Bagirmi in the 1500s.[46] Indeed, Bir b. Idris, a
Sayfawa ruler, died in Bagirmi in c.1421.[47] The Bulala influence in the
northern part of Bagirmi may have sparked the conflict with the Sayfawa lead to
the death of this mai. The Bulala
were even remembered in Kawar for one particularly brutal raid in Bilma during
the 17th century, probably in the early 1600s, when Bulala forces massacred
locals.[48] Intriguingly, Nachtigal recorded a raid from Bagirmi that would
have reached Kawar in the 1600s, possibly referring to the same attack if
Bagirmi and Bulala forces collaborated in a raid.[49] This same Bagirmi mbang,
Burkomanda (r. 1635-1665), had a sister married to the Bulala ruler in
Fitri.[50] Ultimately, in the 1400s and 1500s, the Bulala sultans may have held
more power than the burgeoning kingdom of Bagirmi while also imposing tribute
on lands east of Kanem.
The sultanate in Kanem appears to have maintained practices of the Sayfawa with certain adaptations due to demographic and ecological shifts. In terms of their state’s administrative structure, it appears to have continued the Sayfawa system, with titles like galadima, djerma, yerima, sindilma and more. Such titles still existed among the Bulala in Fitri.[51] It is very likely that the Bulala state managed to impose tribute on parts of the Lake Fitri region, northern Bagirmi, and upon the Kanembu in Kanem for resources. They must have also continued to engage in some degree of trans-Saharan trade through Kawar and perhaps with lands to the east. Within Kanem, their subjects were said to encompass the Tomagheras, Kangus, Koubouri, Tsougourtis, Djiloas, and Bulala.[52] A Kuka population in Gujer may have accompanied the Bulala when they conquered Kanem in the 14th and 15th centuries.[53] Adding further detail is the brief mention of the Bulala by Ahmad Baba of Timbuktu. Writing in response to North Africans about which black population were permissible to enslave, Baba wrote of the Bulala as composed of Muslim Fulani, Shuwa Arabs, and “Sudan” who were sometimes enslaved and sold by Borno.[54] One may surmise that the trona deposits of Foli were also exploited by this point, making salt, trona, livestock, leather and possibly captives probable items of exchange for the economy. Lastly, the Bulala sultans may have played a role in the rise or maintenance of “casted” populations, the Haddad. The common ancestry of some Haddad and the Bulala was still known in the early 20th century.[55] To what extent specific caste-like groups associated with specific types of labor developed in Kanem is unclear, but the Bulala sultans may have played a role in at least continuing it across Kanem.
Another poorly understood
aspect of Kanem’s history is the fall of the Bulala sultanate in the region.
Many sources concur on attributing its decline to the coming of the Tunjur from
Waday. The standard narrative suggests that, following Idris Alooma’s
successful campaigns, the Bulala sultans continued to reside in Kanem and
likely sent tribute to the Sayfawa mai.
However, at some point in the 17th century, after the rise of Waday (likely in
the 1630s, according to Nachtigal’s chronology), part of the Tunjur population
led by a son of the last Tunjur king, Dawud, migrated west. At some point after
the fall of the Bulala sultans in Kanem, Borno sent the first alifa,
Dala Afuno, who ruled from Mao. Zeltner, drawing on Gros’s study of Tunjur oral
traditions and other sources, believed that the Bulala may have gradually
shifted from Kanem due to environmental factors as it became more arid in the
17th century. Furthermore, the Tunjur, who may have begun migrating to Kanem in
the 1630s at the earliest, may not have been powerful enough to seriously
threaten or unseat the Bulala sultanate.[56] Bulala traditions from the Fitri
region shed little further light. A king, Djili Esa Toubou, who had been raised
in Bagirmi, was said to have conquered Fitri from the dry Massoa region.[57]
This Djili Esa Toubo, or Djil Essa Tubo in Hagenbucher’s spelling, was said to
have come to the aid of the Abou Semen against the Kuka and was succeeded by 20
sultans until 1967.[58] This Djil, or Djili, may be equated with the Abd al
Jalil mentioned by Palmer as the first Bulala sultan ruling the Kuka at Gao
(Yao?).[59] This narrative seems to imply that the Bulala had already left
Kanem by the time of Djili Esa Toubo, so possibly in the decades after the rise
of Waday and during or after the immigration of the Tunjur in Kanem. In light
of the uncertainty caused by the lack of firmer dates for the
establishment of Waday, the migration of the Tunjur, the relocation of the
Bulala, and Borno sponsoring an alifa at Mao, one can only follow Zeltner’s
argument for the Tunjur migration in the 1630s. By 1642, the Dala Afuno of Mao
was likely present, probably to restore order in Kanem and ensure the province’s
(re)integration in Borno’s sphere of influence.
Undoubtedly, further
research must be done to clarify, elaborate, and expand on the period of Bulala
domination of Kanem. Sadly, the sources that do exist are Borno-centric or
mainly focus on Kanuri traditions. Deeper examination of Kanembu oral
traditions and songs may shed further light on the period of Bulala rule.
Nonetheless, one can corroborate aspects of the traditional history through a
multiplicity of sources. They are not enough to reconstitute more of Kanem’s
history in the period, but they are revealing. The Bulala appear to have
usurped control of Kanem by the late 14th century, and their state likely
continued practices of the Sayfawa in administrative structure. The state
likely controlled the Fitri region (however loosely) and perhaps parts of the
northern section of Bagirmi. It is similarly likely that the Bulala sultans may
have sponsored the migration of the Kuka into Gujer as well as some of the
Shuwa Arabs. Their state may have reinforced or sponsored caste lineage groups
for specific types of labor and forging. Despite their recurring conflicts with
the Sayfawa maiwa in Borno, close
relations were ensured through marriage alliances and even joint pilgrimages to
Mecca. When relations were cordial or not disrupted by Bulala raids or refusal
to send tribute, they likely enjoyed much local autonomy. It is our hope that
with more surveying in Kanem and dating of sites with brick walls or ruins, the
era of Bulala hegemony may receive further attention.
________________
[1]
Moïse Landeroin, “Notice Historique,” in Documents scientifiques de la
Mission Tilho, 1906-1909, 388.
[2]
Ibid, 354.
[3]
Henri Carbou, La région du Tchad et du Ouadai II, 34.
[4]
Ibid, 51.
[5]
Carbou, La région du Tchad I, 292.
[6]
Ibid, 300.
[7]
Ibid, 301.
[8]
Ibid, 18.
[9]
Ibid, 303.
[10]
Ibid, 305.
[11]
Ibid, 306.
[12]
Ibid, 37.
[13]
Ibid, 44.
[14]
Henri Carbou, La région du Tchad, II, 47.
[15]
H.R. Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs III, 29.
[16]
Lange, Diwan, 79.
[17]
Rémi Dewière, Du lac Tchad à la Mecque, 379.
[18]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs II, 42-43.
[19]
Ibid, 44.
[20]
Lange, Diwan, 79.
[21]
Palmer, “The Bornu Girgam,”79.
[22]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs I, 19.
[23]
Muhammad Nur Alkali, Kanem-Borno Under the Sayfawa, 200.
[24]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs I, 17.
[25]
Lange, Diwan, 76-77.
[26]
Yusufu Bala Usman (editor), Studies in the History of Pre-Colonial
Borno, 165.
[27]
Lange, “L’eviction des Sefuwa du Kanem,” 327.
[28]
Carbou, La région du Tchad II, 34.
[29]
Carbou, La région du Tchad I, 300.
[30]
Jean-Claude Zeltner, Pages d’Histoire du Kanem, pays tchadien,
107.
[31]
Carbou, La région du Tchad I, 301.
[32]
Ibid, 18.
[33]
Lange, Diwan, 76.
[34]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs II, 32.
[35]
Lange, Diwan, 77.
[36]
Ibid.
[37]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs III, 28-29.
[38]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs I, 50.
[39]
Gustav Nachtigal, Sahara and Sudan IV, 34.
[40]
Zeltner, 111.
[41]
Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs I, 17.
[42]
Zeltner, 110.
[43]
Collet Hadrien, “Royal Pilgrims from Takrūr According to ʿAbd al-Qādir
al-Jazīrī (12th–16th Century),”193.
[44]
Carlos Magnavita, “New Luminescence and Radiocarbon Dates for Kanem-Borno
Fired-Brick Elite Sites in Kanem, Chad: Bayesian Chronological Modelling of
Settlement Construction,” 12.
[45]
Zeltner, 151.
[46]
Hints of possible Bulala rule in the north of the future kingdom of Bagirmi
appear in Nachtigal’s account of Bagirmi history. Carbou claims it was actually
the Kuka who imposed tribute on the north of Bagirmi (La région du
Tchad I, 298).
[47]
Lange, Diwan, 77.
[48]
Maurice Abadie, La colonie du Niger, 133.
[49]
Nachtigal, Sahara and Sudan III, 405.
[50]
Ibid.
[51]
Hagenbucher, “Notes sur les Bilala du Fitri,” 50.
[52]
Landeroin, 388.
[53]
Nachtigal, Sahara and Sudan III, 74.
[54]
Ahmad Baba, Miʻrāj al-ṣuʻūd, 48.
[55]
Carbou, La région du Tchad I, 52.
[56]
Zeltner, 192-193.
[57]
Carbou, La region du Tchad I, 308.
[58]
Hagenbucher, 50.
[59] Palmer, Sudanese Memoirs II, 30.
Monday, July 3, 2023
Rambling on Pre-Islamic Kanem Religion
Works Consulted
Barth, Heinrich. Travels and Discoveries in North and Central Africa: Being a Journal of an Expedition Undertaken Under the Auspices of H.B.M.'s Government in the Years 1849-1855. New York: D. Appleton, 1857.
Bjørkelo AJ. State and Society in Three Central Sudanic Kingdoms Kanem-Bornu Bagirmi and Wadai. Bergen: Universitetet i Bergen; 1976.
Bobboyi, Hamidu. The'Ulama of Borno: A study of the relations between scholars and state under the Sayfawa, 1470-1808. Northwestern University, 1992.
Chapelle, Jean. Nomades noirs du Sahara. Paris: Plon, 1958.
Cohen, Ronald. The Kanuri of Bornu. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1967.
Descourtilz, M. E. (Michel Etienne) 1809. Voyages d’un naturaliste. Paris: Dufart, père.
Dewière, Rémi. Du Lac Tchad À La Mecque: Le Sultanat Du Borno Et Son Monde (XVIe - XVIIe Siècle). Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne, 2017.
Galaty, John G., and Pierre Bonte. Herders, Warriors, and Traders: Pastoralism in Africa. Boulder: Westview Press, 1991.
Hopkins, J. F. P., and Nehemia Levtzion. Corpus of Early Arabic Sources for West African History. 1st Princeton: Markus Wiener Publishers, 2000.
Ibn Furṭū, Aḥmad, and Dierk Lange. A Sudanic Chronicle: The Borno Expeditions of Idrīs Alauma (1564-1576) According to the Account of Aḥmad B. Furṭū : Arabic Text, English Translation, Commentary and Geographical Gazetteer. Stuttgart: F. Steiner, 1987.
Koelle, S. W. (Sigismund Wilhelm). African Native Literature, or Proverbs, Tales, Fables, & Historical Fragments in the Kanuri or Bornu Language. To Which Are Added a Translation of the Above and a Kanuri-English Vocabulary. London: Church Missionary House, 1854.
Lange, Dierk. Le Dīwān Des Sultans Du (Kānem-)Bornū: Chronologie Et Histoire D'un Royaume Africain (de La Fin Du Xe Siècle Jusqu'à 1808). Wiesbaden: F. Steiner, 1977.
Magnavita, Carlos, Zakinet Dangbet and Tchago Bouimon, « The Lake Chad region as a crossroads: an archaeological and oral historical research project on early Kanem-Borno and its intra-African connections », Afrique : Archéologie & Arts, 15 | 2019, 97-110.
Palmer, H. R. (Herbert Richmond). The Bornu Sahara and Sudan. Nigeria. J. Murray, 1936.
------. Sudanese Memoirs: Being Mainly Translations of a Number of Arabic Manuscripts Relating to the Central and Western Sudan. 1st ed., new impression. London: Cass, 1967.
Redhouse, J. W. “Translation from the Original Arabic of a History or Journal of the Events Which Occurred during Seven Expeditions in the Land of Kānim, against the Tribes of Bulala, &c., by the Sultan of Burnu, Idris the Pilgrim, Son of ’Ali; Preceded by Some Details of the Sultan’s Ancestors.” Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland 19 (1862): 43–123. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25228715.
Rosman, Abraham. Social Structure and Acculturation Among the Kanuri of Northern Nigeria / by Abraham Rosman. Yale University, 1966.
Tério, Abdelkérim Souleyman, Origine Et Evolution Des Zaghawa: Du Royaume Du Kanem Aux Etats Modernes (VIIIe-XXIe Siècle). N'Djaména, Tchad :Éditions SAO, 2014.
Trimingham, J. Spencer. A History of Islam in West Africa. London: Published for the University of Glasgow by the Oxford U.P
Tubiana, Marie José. Survivances Préislamiques En Pays Zaghawa. Paris: Institut d'ethnologie, 1964.
Unesco. International Scientific Committee for the Drafting of a General History of Africa. General History of Africa. London : Berkeley: Heinemann Educational Books; University of California Press, 1981.
Yusuf, Salahudeen., and Muḥammad Bello. A History of Islam, Scholarship and Revivalism in Western Sudan, Being an Annotated Translation with Introduction of Infaqul-Maisur Fi Tarikh Bilad Al-Tukur of Sultan Muhammad Bello Bin Fodio Zaria: Tamaza, 2013.



