Showing posts with label Georges Corvington. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Georges Corvington. Show all posts

Thursday, February 19, 2026

Port-au-Prince au cours des ans (1804-1888)


The volume covering Port-au-Prince from 1804-1888 in Georges Corvington's Port-au-Prince au cours des ans is very important for establishing the pattern of urban (under)development that has characterized Port-au-Prince throughout Haiti's history as an independent nation. Of course, Corvington focuses on the history of Port-au-Prince's urban confines, characteristics, economy, and cultural life means the larger story of Haitian underdevelopment and peripheral status in the world system of the 19th century are largely ignored. But any full understanding of why Port-au-Prince, despite some positive reforms in the years of Geffrard's presidency, or even part of the Salomon years, often failed to consistently maintain urban policies to rebuild or expand infrastructure, must be seen within the larger structural problems of Haitian political economy beyond the capital. By narrowing one's focus on the capital, however, the nefarious consequences of Haiti's structural woes are immediately clear, elucidating why the city in 2026 is unfortunately like its 19th century counterpart.

While the seeds were undoubtedly sown in the colonial era, this volume demonstrates how the various governments for most of Haiti's first century after the Revolution failed to manage and sustain the capital's growth. The perennial problem of instability and frequent revolutions, fires, natural disasters, or economic woes made the capital one which often lacked the infrastructure to adequate house its people. In addition, a large class of urban poor who were either unemployed or underemployed were already evident, with beggars known for congregating in public places and sleeping by the cathedral. Like today, the city's poor roads, badly managed tramway service (driven by horses in the 1870s and 1880s), and the failure of the municipal and national authorities to maintain sanitation, roads, or the distribution of water made much of the capital an unagreeable place. 

Despite these many problems, the capital was not without its charms. For instance, the Geffrard years witnessed a flourishing moment for the elite and bourgeois while Salomon's tenure saw the city expand further, beginning to look more like the capital of today spatially. Various governments did endeavor to improve infrastructure (often running out of funding before completion or relying on questionable concessionaires). The city's urban poor and laboring classes were actively involved in Carnival and the bourgeois homes formed elite salons or patronized theaters and high-end shops. Some degree of mixed neighborhoods could be seen in Bel-Air when petite-bourgoisie families established homes in the area or even parts of the Bord-de-Mer where families with means lived relatively close to impoverished quarters. Naturally, the seeds of the suburbanization and wealthy enclaves also developed in the 1800s, with Turgeau being one of the desirable neighborhoods of the time. 

But those on the other side of the tracks became a burgeoning problem for different neighborhoods, not just Bel-Air or Morne-a-Tuf. The capital's frequent fires, political turmoil, and the government's dependence on German or other foreign interests severely limited the ability of the state to adequately manage and restore the city after its numerous fires. These sadly meant that, as the population gradually grew, the state was usually not able to ensure urban infrastructure or services that would make the city livable. Naturally, this problem became extreme in the second half of the 20th century, but one can already detect traces of it in the 19th century. Even a Salomon who partly encouraged home ownership on the new outskirts of the city or the growth of charity, social aid, and Catholic churches, schools, and hospitals were not adequate to meet the challenge. Not wholly explained by Corvington but very significant, the urban masses who supported the charismatic Salnave represent one eruption of proletarian or urban poor assertion. Although failing with the fall of Salnave and the return to power of the old bourgeois interests, the specter of the urban poor remained a threat to established interests. For that reason, one wishes Corvington explored more deeply the question of crime, labor (domestic servants, artisans, stevedores), and religion or spirituality of the urban poor and workers. For instance, how did Vodou shape the lives of the urban poor and neighborhood organization or politics? To what extent did the Church's new chapels and parishes in the growing city shape popular Catholic identity and practice? Their lives are partly represented in his numerous references to areas like Bel-Air, but a deeper sense of their class position and daily experiences may have helped readers to understand how inequality was exacerbated whilst benefitting the elite and political classes. 

In other words, we should probably read the subsequent volumes of the series. There Corvington would have had more sources to draw from to paint a more complete social picture of the Haitian capital. Nonetheless, this is a fine start for a basic overview of how Port-au-Prince did evolve in the 19th century. Corvington is careful with sources, often relying on newspapers from the period in question, foreigners' accounts, memoires, and using maps and photographs to display the changes over time. Perhaps engaging with oral traditions and family histories, especially among families from the lower-class or middle classes could have helped to fill in the gaps for much of the 19th century.

Saturday, November 29, 2014

Port-au-Prince mon seul et unique amour


Arnold Antonin's documentary on the life and work of Georges Corvington is endearing and nostalgic but avoids romanticizing Port-au-Prince's history. Beginning with the life of Georges Corvington, his education, and his vast library that was lost in the 2010 earthquake that nearly killed him, the rest of the film goes over his magisterial history of Port-au-Prince from the colonial era to Magloire in the republished CIDIHCA volumes of Port-au-Prince au cours de ans. Along the way, we see interviews with Georges Corvington and others who knew him, such as Michel Hector and Frankétienne discussing how Corvington was committed to the city of Port-au-Prince's history and how the city was his only love (Corvington never married). The greatest thing about this documentary was the plethora of photographs, images, and video clips of Port-au-Prince in the various stages of its history, including some delightful Haitian mereng (Lamothe's "La Dangereuse" can be heard at various times) and jazz music. 

Port-au-Prince's early history, its history of fires and political upheaval, the rapid urban growth, the rise of more architecturally beautiful public buildings in various phases, the impact of US Occupation (the rise of more public administration buildings, particularly under Borno's presidency), the colonial period (which was the origin of building most of the city in wood from the 18th century to the 20th century), the 19th century (which did feature monuments, such as the National Cathedral and various presidential palaces), etc. are all covered in the film (including development in Port-au-Prince of tramways, more monumental architecture, the Bicentennial Celebration, the Belle Époque years of the 1950s). The film challenges notions that no Haitian government has ever invested in or tried to change Haiti, and looking at Haiti's urban history is clearly something that merits further investigation beyond Port-au-Prince. Indeed, it would be excellent to find more urban historians who can carry on Corvington's legacy for different Haitian cities, such as Les Cayes (where the Corvington family resided before Port-au-Prince), Jacmel, and Gonaives.

Overall, this short documentary, under an hour in length, is a great introduction to the works of Corvington. Although his vast library was destroyed in the 2010 earthquake that left Corvington under rubble, his legacy can and should live on in additional scholarly work on Haiti's urban history. The astounding visuals also complement quite well the interviews with Corvington and those who knew him. My only complaint is the shortness of the film, which means less detail, and the lack of special features on the DVD to explore some of the sources for the visuals, music, and Corvington's works. Nontheless, the numerous details and tantalizing facts about Port-au-Prince (such as its first film projection, back in 1896, the development of the Bel-Air neighborhood and the rise of new residential areas, such as Turgeau and Bois Verna). Furthermore, Corvington's impressive work on Port-au-Prince's history was all the more so because he did not travel abroad to research, but collected his sources in Haiti and used his library to write instead of relying on foreign archives.