Wednesday, March 22, 2023

Meroitic Lower Nubia

Millet's dissertation, "Meroitic Nubia," was not what we expected. Instead of a speculative and dated interpretation of Meroitic Lower Nubia and the Dodekaschoinos, Millet's essay focuses on interpreting the Meroitic inscriptions and texts to make sense of northern Nubia's elite administrative, religious, and kinship structures. Due to our failure to make sense of most of the Meroitic language, however, there is a lot of guesswork and attempts to corroborate guesses with Demotic and Greek sources or texts. With those limitations in mind, Millet nonetheless raises a number of interesting questions about the role of northern Nubia during the 3rd century of our era. 

According to Millet, the region's growing importance must have been linked to the adoption of the waterwheel, gold mining at Wadi el-Allaqi, and trade routes through the desert to Egypt. Intriguingly, Millet also proposes that Lower Nubia's economic importance was also based on trade with the west and southwest, with Darfur and Kordofan. The spread of the camel and Meroe's interests in peace with the desert nomads (ancestors of the Beja and others) must have been, in part, motivated by a desire to provide security for trade routes to Egypt. Although Meroe appears to have "shared" the Dodekaschoinos with the Ptolemaic and Roman rulers of Egypt, the continued importance of the temple at Philae represented another interest of Meroites in Lower Nubia. 

As for the general thrust of his thesis, on collateral inheritance of titles in Meroitic Nubia or the degree to which his tentative genealogies of elite families in the region can be substantiated, we assume more recent scholarship has partly addressed this. Our friends, the Wayekiye family, for instance, must be one of the fascinating families for analysis because of their education and links to the princely Akin lineage. Were they and other similar families also investing in land, and exploiting tenant farmers? Furthermore, it would be interesting to see if the relationship of Meroitic Lower Nubia to the heartland of the state was comparable to Lower Nubia's relation to Dongola in the medieval era. Certainly, the survival of Meroitic culture to some extent and a framework assuming cultural continuity would suggest this. 

Mona and San German

 


While reading Caldera Ortiz's Historia de San Germán: Nuevos Hallazgos para su estudio genealógico, 1512-1712 we found out that the cacique of Mona was living in San German during the 1590s. Diego Ramirez wasn't even born on Mona or Puerto Rico but came from the mainland or South America. Was this around the time when Indians of Mona began settling in the hills of San German? And from there, to Indiera and Añasco? What was going on in the 1590s that, by then, pushed the cacique of Mona to inhabit San German?

Tuesday, March 21, 2023

Rosaura a las diez

La Versión de Matilde

Inspector Baigorri, voy a decirle lo que ha pasado en la Madrileña con respeto a Camilo Canegato. Al principio, la primera vez que lo vi, mis hermanas y yo pensábamos que Camilo era tímido, callado y muy divertido. A diferencia de los otros huéspedes, mis hermanas y yo podíamos tutear a Camilo y pasar un rato. A causa de su edad y apariencia física, Camilo era al igual que un amigo. Camilo no podría matarla porque su carácter no es violento. Nadie puede ser tan simpático, Inspector Baigorri. 

Antes de la llegada de las cartas de Rosaura, el comportamiento de Camilo era normal. No hizo nada insólito y no tenía correspondencia con otros. La única persona que visitó el cuarto de Camilo era una mujer fea que planchó su ropa. Después de unos años, Camilo recibió cartas de Rosaura. Las cartas llegaron cada miércoles y Camilo dejó de pasar tiempo con mis hermanas y yo. Camilo parecía un hermano en nuestra familia, pero Rosaura lo robó. Por eso mi mamá y yo nos sentíamos insultadas. En cuanto a su edad, todavía creo que Rosaura le mintió a Camilo. Hoy en día las mujeres jóvenes no envían cartas a sus amantes como Rosaura. Además envió una trenza a Camilo, demasiado tradicional.  Desde el punto de vista de mi mamá, esta hazaña era romántica. Por otro lado mis hermanas y yo dijimos que las acciones de Rosaura no correspondieron con una mujer joven.

Cuando Camilo nos dijo la verdad sobre Rosaura, no creí nada. Nos mostró el retrato de ella y no era hermosísima. En vez de hermosa podría decir que Rosaura era guapa. En el caso de que usted sospeche que yo esté celosa de la relación entre los dos, no entiende la realidad de la situación. Espero que me entienda, Inspector Baigorri. No estoy enamorada de Camilo. Es un hermano en mi familia, y Camilo no la mató. Durante las semanas que Rosaura vivía en la Madrileña, nunca vi una manifestación de amor. Ellos no se abrazaron y no usaron palabras de amor como una pareja de enamorados. Entonces esta relación sin amor tuvo que terminar. Sin embargo, Rosaura no fue asesinada por Camilo. Yo dudaba que Camilo estuviera el único hombre en el hotel cuando Rosaura se murió. Es posible que su padre contrata asesinos para eliminarla. Según Camilo, su padre no dio permisión a Rosaura para casarse. Un hombre tan rico como el padre de Rosaura podría encontrar gente para matarla.

Medieval Nubia

Giovanni Ruffini's ambitiously titled Medieval Nubia: A Social and Economic History asserts a number of compelling and, despite its limited sources, plausible theories for Christian Nubia. Instead of seeing Makuria or Dotawo as lacking private land tenure or a monetized economy, Ruffini draws from the Qasr Ibrim land sales and letters to argue Makuria was a mixture of classical Mediterranean and local Sudanese traditions. Like Spaulding and others who have analyzed various aspects of Nubia's vast history, Ruffini argues for cultural continuity as a guiding theme for making sense of Nubia. Numerous examples are cited in the text of Meroitic and even pharaonic Egyptian influences in medieval Nubian religion, culture, and customs. The Choiak public festival, for instance, was likely of Osirian origin and survived in Coptic and Nubian Christian practice. Nubian rituals of today that include dipping new-born infants into the Nile and referencing Mary likely date from the Christian period, too. 

Thus, from the late Meroitic or Late Antique era until about 1821, one can arguably find much continuity across the political dimensions of the region. This can be highlighted with the adoption of the waterwheel and the role of the Nile and local ecology in both Lower and Upper Nubia. However, Nubia was, through thousands of years of contact with Egypt and the Mediterranean world, also a recipient of those influences. That impact can be seen in the Greco-Roman and Coptic traces in medieval Nubia's legal traditions. Naturally, then, one cannot be surprised to find similarities between Old Nubian land documents and those in Coptic in Egypt. Moreover, the importance of Greek as a living and even divine language used for bilingual Biblical texts, titles, amulets, and rituals attests to the survival of Roman and Byzantine influences long after Egypt fell under Muslim rule. Ruffini's Medieval Nubia attempts to demonstrate this signifiance of the classical Mediterranean's legacy through Qasr Ibrim's surviving documents, plus occasional epigraphic, ethnographic, literary, archaeological, and additional sources.

Unfortunately, our limited sources leads one to think Ruffini's study remains too speculative. While likely correct about the existence of private land tenure in Lower Nubia (and throughout Nubia, probably), much of the analysis of the Qasr Ibrim documents relies on speculation. We await further confirmation from Dongola, Soba, and other sites to ascertain the degree to which some of these speculative conclusions can be borne out. Nonetheless, Ruffini's analysis is persuasive based on the assumption of cultural continuity and the comparative data from other parts of Sudan and Egypt. The implications of this suggest a much wider territory included within what is usually considered "Mediterranean." In addition, it suggests medieval Nubia's land was productive or profitable and that elites who engaged in land sales were socially linked to the ecclesiastical and royal authorities. This elite group, whose conspicuous consumption through feasting accompanied land sales, also appears in the external Arabic sources in occasional revolts, conflicts with Nubian kings, and relations with Egypt. Alas, we are still left in the dark about the slaves, peasants, tenant farmers, and other groups in this complex society. 

The internal sources also call into question some of the problematic assumptions made by Western scholars who heavily rely on the external textual references. Some, like al-Masudi definitely reflect what might be considered a racial bias, although perhaps Ruffini overstates the case in regards to medieval Arab views of black Africans. Regardless, medieval Nubia represents a case in which one must carefully use the medieval Arabic sources when analyzing societies of the Sudan. Without understanding local dynamics, local sources, and the literary topos of the outside writers, one can perpetuate biases and omissions from the original writers, such as al-Masudi. Unfortunately, we have a lot more to uncover from Old Nubian sources and archaeological research before we can confirm some of Ruffini's conclusions. Research on Alwa would be particularly interesting here, since the external sources suggest it was wealthier than Makuria. Alwa's southern location and less reliance on the Nile also raises interesting questions about the periods of unification of medieval Nubia and Alwa's relations with societies further east and west. Either way, the future of Nubiology promises to be exciting.

Saturday, March 18, 2023

Askia Muhammad and al-Maghili

John Hunwick's translation and commentary on al-Maghili's replies to 7 questions from Askia Muhammad is a difficult source for non-specialists. To truly understand al-Maghili's responses and the complex Islamic intellectual tradition he drew upon, one must have some basic familiarity with Islamic civilization, jurisprudence, and political ideology. Hunwick's introductory sections and commentary tremendously help readers make sense of this context. However, the main benefit of reading Shari'a in Songhay : the replies of al-Maghili to the questions of Askia al-Hajj Muhammad is in the glimpses of Songhay social, economic, and political life it provides. For instance, we learn of the practice of nude virgin women traveling through the streets of Jenne or the practitioners of a fox cult who appear to have been Dogon. Or the Masufa presence among Fulani marauders who were a source of concern for Askia Muhammad. These examples highlight the degree to which demographic changes, insecurity, and local cultural practices were in a state of flux across the Middle Niger. They also attest to the partly Islamized nature of the Western Sudan and its vast heterogeneity in cultural and religious identities. Since the date of al-Maghili's replies was in the early part of Askia Muhammad's reign, one must also keep in mind that conditions during his later years or those of his successors likely differed in key ways. For example, Askia Muhammad's expansion of the empire and the degree to which subsequent askias balanced secular government with Islamic precepts or the guidance of the scholars shows political dynamism and possible sources of internal societal conflict. We only wish al-Maghili and Askia Muhammad's secretary had revealed a little more about so-called "traditional" religions, practices of rituals by local Muslims, or the actual experiences of the peasantry and enslaved population.

Friday, March 17, 2023

Isla del Encanto

Looks like we are now in the throes of a full-fledged salsa obsession. Our last salsa phase was probably 6 or 7 years ago, and we barely scratched the surface of the genre. Anyway, this particularly catchy gem about Puerto Rico as an "Edenic Land" is something we are listening to on repeat. The lyrics allude to all the stereotypical things one expects in a song about Puerto Rico, but an overall excellent performance. 

Wednesday, March 15, 2023

Pedro Navaja

The culprit for our renewed interest in West Side Story is "Pedro Navaja" from the 1970s. Salsa is not our major genre, but this blog's ongoing obsession with Latin music is forcing us to visit or revisit old classics we have sadly forgotten or neglected.